Happy Monday, collectors!

Again, it’s strange for me to be telling a good Topps story after I shared a ton of conspiracy theories about them and criticism of them on Sunday, but here we are.

My friend Kevin pulled the following redemption over a year ago:

He has since watched as more recent autographs from both players have been pulled and sold, so he emailed Topps to ask them about the status. They told him it wasn’t available.

Kevin texted me something to the effect of, “I’m shooting my shot,” and sent me a photo of his email attempt to get something big from Topps:

That’s a good email! I was still skeptical, though, because it’s Topps.

But they surprised me:

Uhhh that’s pretty good!

Kevin obviously accepted, and they shipped them immediately:

That’s a pretty big score, if you ask me. Most of the redemption “replacements” I’ve seen have been total losses.

Have you seen a redemption replacement this good?

PRESENTED BY THE PENNYSLEEVER

Here are the products that I use from The Pennysleever:

More Details On The Skenes Debut Patch Auto

I already had this issue written and scheduled when I popped open Twitter late Sunday evening and discovered that Cllct had written a story with a damning detail about the Paul Skenes debut patch auto:

Remember, on my Sunday Clearing the Bases video, we wondered about this detail and if Topps / Fanatics knew and didn’t tell collectors, keeping box prices artificially inflated in the interim. Now we know that they did.

And there’s this:

Bad look.

2 AMA Questions

I forgot to answer two questions on my AMA, so here they are, followed by my answers:

To Joseph: no, I have never had a major find of any kind, unfortunately. It’s been a huge dream of mine since I was a kid. I’m almost 46 now and still think about it often.

To Ron:

I’ve heard millions, and that makes sense. 120,000 go to the National, and that’s a small fraction of the hobby world.

If 1% of Americans collect, that’s almost 4 million people. I would guess that as a high end of a range. Maybe 2-4 million?

What do you think?

Best TV Shows

I also promised to list my favorite tv shows.

I already listed my favorite dramas:

  • Breaking Bad

  • The Sopranos

  • The Wire

  • The Americans

  • Better Call Saul

Then I also love The Shield, The Leftovers, Succession, and Ozark.

For current dramas:

  • White Lotus

  • Squid Game

  • Severance

  • Last Of Us

  • Night Agent

  • Beef

  • Silo (kind of)

  • Shrinking (also hilarious)

  • Fallout

  • Day of the Jackal

  • Lincoln Lawyer

Yeah, I like tv.

As for comedies:

  • Curb Your Enthusiasm

  • Seinfeld

  • Brooklyn 99

  • Always Sunny

  • Arrested Development

  • Veep

  • The League

  • Silicon Valley

  • The Office (US)

  • Nathan For You

  • Detroiters

  • I Think You Should Leave

  • Mr. Show

  • Schitt’s Creek

  • Ghosts

  • Parks & Rec

🗣️ YouTube Comment Of The Week

Probably not ever going to happen, but I liked this idea from Heather:

🎬 Upcoming Videos

  • Eventually I’ll do another Attic Find Friday — I have a bunch of these again, including an old one that I reached out to the subjects of and got a bunch of info

  • #49-45 of my ACE 100 list

  • A subscriber’s killer music card collection — I keep putting this one off because it’s big and intimidating

  • Amazing ticket collection

📩 Upcoming Newsletters

  • The greatest bobblehead collection I’ve ever seen

  • Missing Caitlin Clark card in Panini checklist?

  • A 25-year wait for a collectible comes to an end

  • A crazy Topps redemption story

🎬 Channel Highlights From the Past Week

My first AMA was fun and received good feedback, so I’ll probably do another.

My big pickup video:

🎁 My Pickup Of The Week

I already mentioned this, but I bought 3 cards off Chris Sewall from his recent video. One of them is in this screenshot below, another is also in this handful, and the third one was in the same box.

Chris gave me a killer deal, and for that I am grateful.

Click to start video here

I also bought a couple of items from Jeremy Donson, the Texas Snowman.

I haven’t received any of them yet, but hope to this week.

👻 Brief Horror Movie Review of the Week

After I talked about Child’s Play on my AMA, I watched it with my 15-year-old Sunday morning. I watched it a ton as a kid in the late-’80s and early ‘90s, but didn’t remember much.

It held up pretty well! I’ll watch a couple more, and then move on to the tv show, which I didn’t even know existed until someone commented it.

3 out of 5 stars.

Health Update

Starting weight: 241.2

Current weight: 235.8

Weight lost: 5.4 pounds (2.2%)

Goal weight: 210

Loss required: 31.2 pounds, or 12.9%

Back to where I was a week ago. This is all mental for me. I can still physically lose weight quickly; it’s the drive and motivation that is a struggle.

🔗 Links:

On this date in sports history: 55 years ago today, on January 27th 1970, the Pittsburgh Steelers select Louisiana Tech QB Terry Bradshaw with the first pick in the NFL draft.

Reply

Avatar

or to participate

Avatar

Derek Ryan1 year ago

I had the same issue with an Acuna Jr/Riley Patch Auto /25. It was from 22 Update and 6-12 months later I see 2023 products with both of them having on card and sticker autos in product. I checked in with Topps after seeing this and they told me it would be ready in X amount of time. That time comes and goes and they say sorry it will be ready in X amount of time. The time comes and goes give me $30 in credit and say sorry we don't know when it will be ready.
I end up getting the card after this year after about 18 months and about a dozen products where both players had live autos. Sadly mine was a sticker auto I am happy with the card though, but I wish I would have known to try this at the time.

Avatar

Mike Junk Wax HeroAuthor1 year ago

Yeah I wouldn’t have thought this would work.

Avatar

Oliver Tsay1 year ago

I really don't want to create any more conspiracy theories, buy I can't help wonder why those replacement cards are available from Topps? Did they hold back high end inserts from getting inserted into the packs or did they buy them back for these occasions?

Avatar

Mike Junk Wax HeroAuthor1 year ago

It's a good question... the 2021 Shohei was likely from an expired redemption. Not sure about the 2023. Could've been a redemption that was rejected by the person who pulled it.

Avatar

Dave Lachey1 year ago

Happy Monday Mike, regarding the number of current collectors, I think the number of 2 to 4 million "active" collectors sounds about right. But considering the number of Sports fans I think there are millions of passive collectors and others who remain on the sidelines for various reasons. I talk to people all the time who have cards stashed away and maybe some day they will return to the hobby as I did. And I was lucky enough to pull Terry Bradshaw's RC from a pack back in the day. I had it graded a few years ago and it received a PSA 6. A bit under graded IMO but that was at the start of PSA's tougher grading standards. Beautiful card but tough due to the orange border.

Avatar

Mike Junk Wax HeroAuthor1 year ago

Nice pull, Dave!

Avatar

Paulo Adams1 year ago

Holy cow! I'm not even a fan of ultra modern and I can see the insane value returned as a replacement for the bizarrely unavailable Henderson/Rutschman auto. That process and email Kevin sent should serve as an absolute template for how to deal with screw-ups like this from Topps. Congrats Kevin!

Avatar

Mike Junk Wax HeroAuthor1 year ago

Same!

Avatar

Paulo Adams1 year ago

As an auctioneer and antique dealer I've never made any major card finds, the best was probably a couple shoe boxes of mixed 1970s baseball, basketball, and hockey cards with some nice rookie Hall of Famers or a couple binders of vintage cards that had a single odd post-war outlier: a Bowman Hank Aaron rookie card that was autographed ( submitted it to PSA/DNA and it graded 2/9).

I did, however, just make a major discovery this weekend, which will be of little interest to card fanatics, but definitely interests me. A colleague bought a condo with contents that's been vacant for 13 years. It's filled with antiques and artwork - hundreds of pieces. It's going to be a blast going through all that! I've already found a few items that'll sell in the hundreds or thousands of dollar.

Avatar

Mike Junk Wax HeroAuthor1 year ago

That's awesome!!

Avatar

Bench Fan1 year ago

I thought Kevin's request was not serious. Like, "You screwed me on Gunnar, so I would like the moon as a replacement." They not only gave him the moon, but a free hobby box as well. Man. Lesson: Ask for the moon, because Topps clearly keeps some elite cards out of circulation!

Avatar

Mike Junk Wax HeroAuthor1 year ago

Right! I did not expect them to acquiesce.

Avatar

Brent D1 year ago

Now we need to know - did he open the Topps Dynasty Box?? Any hits in there?

Avatar

Mike Junk Wax HeroAuthor1 year ago

He did, and there wasn't anything good. Yelich auto.

Avatar

Allan Kotmel1 year ago

If you liked The Americans, check out The Diplomat, also starring Keri Russel. They are two seasons in with a third confirmed.

Avatar

Mike Junk Wax HeroAuthor1 year ago

I watched half of the first season and just couldn't get through it. I love Keri Russell though.

Avatar

jim zhou1 year ago

This is nuts. I pulled a redemption for a Altuve/Todd Kalas booklet 1/1, waited 7 months, saved every single PDF with redemptions, didn't see a single pull from the series (this remains true today). https://www.sportscardspro.com/game/baseball-cards-2024-topps-tribute-calling-the-shot-dual-autograph/jose-altuve-todd-kalas-black-ctsda-ak is the card. Asked for replacement and got a Altuve Patch Auto /5 that graded out to be an PSA 8. From 2023 Dynasty. After grading costs and fees I got $300 or so for it. Topps know that I'm an Angels fan and the kicker was that the patch had "WS" on it and the whole time I was wondering if Altuve's wife was ok with it. Felt like a giant middle finger at me.It's not even a good troll since it lacked subtlety, but it was screwed up nonetheless. I read all of the terms (I'm THAT guy, yes, this is the first backfire) so there shouldn't be recourse. Even their ToS is a lie.

I do know how to get a job with just a cover letter. This should've be cake. Argh.