or to participate
Michael Creeden1 year ago
According to Oxford Language Dictionary, the world grail can be defined as "a thing that is eagerly pursued or sought after." Your approach seems spot-on to me. I 100% agree with your take on "grails" based on that definition, and frankly, my own pursuit of similar cards. Very few people land one "grail" and then just stop collecting. Most of us want more cards, even if the sizes of our lists are different. Some of us may want a 100-card collection. Some of us want a 500 card collection. Just because we may land a grail does not mean our pursuit of more grails ends. That's my story and I am sticking to it.

Mike Junk Wax HeroAuthor1 year ago
Well said
Corey In Cream City1 year ago

Mike Junk Wax HeroAuthor1 year ago
Good comment, Corey. I try to be careful with my words. If I'm calling someone the GOAT, I'm careful to say what they're the GOAT of. I think you can be the GOAT MLB centerfielder or NBA center, for instance.
Bench Fan1 year ago
I think "grail" is an individual thing. For some, an Aaron rookie might be because it is one of the hobby's iconic cards and the price for even a low grade is out of reeach. My PSA 2 copy cost nearly $2K, which is beyond many collectors. Yet there are plenty of Aaron rookies, hundreds on eBay right now in PSA and SGC holders. For someone who can acquire an Aaron rookie, perhaps a 1933 Goudey Ruth, or a T206 Cobb. is a grail. Next step up? Maybe a 1952 Topps Mantle is a grail, or a Jackie Robinson rookie. For yet others, the only Holy Grail is in the Bible.

Mike Junk Wax HeroAuthor1 year ago
Aaron rookie is one of my grails too
Eric Antanitus1 year ago
I think you get one grail card and the rest are goals. I don't love the term "grail" to mean multiple things; I think of it solely as a religious term about one object but I get that it's used in common vernacular. That one grail card has to be so out of reach that you'd have to devote your life to working hard, scrimping and saving, and winning the lotto to obtain it.

Mike Junk Wax HeroAuthor1 year ago
I totally get that perspective, Eric. Thanks for chiming in!
Derek K1 year ago
I don't like the idea of having just one grail. One of the best part of card collecting is the continued chase of many desirable cards. I have personal grail cards that are essentially valueless monitarily. Then there are the grails that most everyone agrees are super valuable due to their scarcity and/or pedigree.

Mike Junk Wax HeroAuthor1 year ago
Yes!
Dave Lachey1 year ago
Grail is by definition "the object of an extended or difficult quest". There are other definitions but I think this one best applies to our hobby. When you consider budget and condition of cards it becomes a very individual pursuit. Those cards should have significant meaning and sentimental value above the others. I have at least 40-50 cards I consider grails in my collection, about 5% of my cards. I couldn't pick just one if I had to. If I had to part with a large part of my collection I would try very hard to keep the 5%.

Mike Junk Wax HeroAuthor1 year ago
Well said, Dave.
Greg Armentrout1 year ago
This used to be called a "white whale". A card you pursue for a long time and finally capture. That name may be more conducive to having more than one in your collecting career. It's still rare and unique, even though it may not be the only one to exist ever.

Mike Junk Wax HeroAuthor1 year ago
I like it
Derek Ryan1 year ago
We all have inconsequential things that Irk us far more than they should. The Grail thing just might be his. I do agree that technically Grail should be 1 thing, not many things and unchanging changing. It's like having multiple Favorites. You can really only have 1 favorite, but we know what you mean. That being said it doesn't bother me calling multiple things Grails, as we know what you mean by it.

Mike Junk Wax HeroAuthor1 year ago
Thanks Derek
David Thompson1 year ago
I really wouldn’t be a stickler on a definition of grails; unless we’re talking about the Holy Grail. : D I can’t see any purpose in making an issue of this. Strange really. I’m totally fine with multiple grails per your preference. You do you, Mike.

Mike Junk Wax HeroAuthor1 year ago
Thanks David!